Saturday, January 30, 2010

Ginew/ Golden Eagle

Hi everyone-

For a Public Life Literature class I am currently taking, I am doing a sort of service-learning track where I will be starting a volunteer job at the Ginew/Golden Eagle organization on Cedar in Minneapolis (I think in close proximity to the Little Earth American Indian community). I'm really excited because I will be working with Native American youth and can possibly ask them about their position on the topic of mascots? Does anyone else think that is a good idea to include in our research?

Thursday, January 28, 2010

Scandinavians' feelings towards Vikings...

Something to think about- What is the difference between mascots like the Vikings and mascots of Native Americans? People of Scandinavian descent don't show nearly as much adversion to the portrayal of the Vikings as Native Americans do about teams like the Fighting Sioux or Chicago Blackhawks.

Some ideas:
-The Vikings are extinct. Natives Americans are obviously still alive.
-The integrity of the mascot and the way it's portrayed.

Wednesday, January 27, 2010

Mascot Jumping Off Points

I think Alex wanted us to do a case study or two regarding mascots in the five state area, this way we will find the most people in the easiest way with opinions regarding semi-local mascots. I feel that when looking at the etymology of the word mascot, one should also consider what the symbol of the mascot means to a fan (this will most likely come up in research). There is something strange about how one can cheer for the Vikings as a whole team, but on average not be able to name more than a handful of players. Thus the fans dont identify the team as individuals but instead as collective abstractly shaped by the symbol with which they are recognized. I thought it would be interesting to ask U of M students how they feel being a Gopher. Gophers are nuisances to most humans, and I dont feel too wonderful about the icon of my school being more or less vermin.

I spoke with Alex after class, and I am sure you read it in the syllabus also, but the page requirement for this project sits at 25. This breaks down into a couple of pages of writing for each of us. Luckily, this is not going to be as stressful as we all think it is. I think it would be an effective and pertinent strategy to split into 4-5 smaller subtopics, as have been mentioned in the earlier posts, and in smaller groups work on a 5-6 page essay regarding a single topic. As I said during class, I will do the editing for this project as a whole. This is my proposal for everyone,

By March 26th, this is the last Friday in March, I would like 5-6 page essays on each of the topics we decide to research. This will give me enough time over the weekend to read, edit, and write the larger paper connecting the dots between the subtopics and addressing a main thesis. That following Monday I will have been able to email you the draft I have completed and we can talk about it in class, this will then give me one more week to do finishing touches and re-writes. I will make a note about this now, that is proofread your papers. I dont want to be handed something wrought with punctuation, spelling, and grammar errors that could have been easily rectified with proofreading and quick edits.

How does this sound?

Tuesday, January 26, 2010

My 2 cents

I was thinking that for the paper we could cover all sides:
Pro
Con
Interviews (the Peoples thoughts)
History of Teams with Native mascots and the controversies surrounding them
(a basic overview)

I say this because I doubt that we would be able to make this paper into a one sided issue and it would be nice to have it be journalistic in the sense that it represents ALL sides because everyone's voice should be heard. It would also be nice to have an overview of this issue to ground it in something that is unbiased (or as unbiased as "facts" can be).

Also for a time line in weeks:
1 (now) initial individual research
2 (Feb 1-7) Assign teams and meet IRL or Virtually
3 (Feb 8-14) research
4 (Feb 15-21) write
5 (Feb 22-28) rough drafts posted to blog and read by others with feedback e-mailed to authors
6 (Mar 1-7) revision
7 (Mar 8-14) finalization

E-mail all final products to Mark on Monday March 15th

If I got that right the weeks should come out to be in to the editors during spring break.

You don't need to post what you think of the time line (as agreed we will go over this at the beginning of class next Monday). But if you could "comment" (see button below) about the outline for the paper (see above) that would be great.

The fighting Sioux

Washington Post has an article from 2005 in which the use of "the fighting Sioux" mascot is a big controversy at North Dakota university. NCAA has banned the use of Native American logos by teams and the school is divided in pro/con groups. Some say the use of such logos is discriminatory while others say the use of these logos helps the image of the tribes. Anyway, if we can come up with a short introduction about mascots linked to the tribes and a thesis in which we support or not the use of mascots then we can start mapping researchable topics in support of our thesis. My idea is that if all in the group brainstorm of a couple of issues then we can go on our ways to research them and write 2-3 pages about it for a total of 25. Some can interview people on reservations or at the casinos. Others can research the use of mascots in US history or cases in courts regarding legal issues from mascots depicting tribal images, et cetera.

Monday, January 25, 2010

Notes from class

Alex said we should stick within the 5 state area. I am pretty sure he means North/South Dakota, Minnesota and Wisconsin....but which is the 5th? Iowa? Illinois? He suggested we look up the etymology of the word "mascot". He also brought up checking into how native youth feel about cheering for a team that has an Indian/Native mascot.