Sunday, March 28, 2010

Paper

The history of mascots dates back to cavemen and early societies who hunted for their livelihood. Early accounts of masked creatures, often resembling animals were drawn or etched on cave walls and depicted in ancient art. Totem poles were filled with likenesses of animals in ancient cultures. These likenesses are much like the concept of the team mascots evident on football fields and basketball courts. Usually in ancient times the history of mascots' shows that these likenesses were often worshiped. This was especially true during times of hunting and harvest. Ancient tribal people would dress up in the likeness of animals or those on totem poles to incite goodwill from them. They believed this would help with successful hunts and bountiful harvests. Also, ancient cultures would dress up in masks or animal like figures for purposes of fertility. Many would dance in the "mascot" like costume to bring about fertility for people in their tribe or village” said Amy Nutt in her article of History of Mascots.
Mascots, a term for persons, animals or objects thought to bring luck, includes anything used to represent a group with a public identity schools, professional sports team, society, military unit or brand name. Mascots can also be used as spokespeople for products, such as Trix the Rabbit. Often mascots are used in the community to create enthusiasm for the group and are often clothed in a costume.
According to the Online Etymology Dictionary, the word mascot dates back to the dialectic use in Provence and Gascony, where it was used to describe the luck it brought to the household. They suggested that the word came from masque, the French word for a child born with a caul, which created a lucky destiny of such children. The word became popular in 1880, when the French composer Audran wrote a comic strip entitled La Mascotte. This was so popular that it was translated into English as The Mascot and was redefined as any animal, person or object that brings good luck.
When choosing a mascot, often the community picks something that reflects a desired quality; one that is competitive in nature personified by warriors or predatory animals. They may also symbolize a local or regional trait.
According to Ruth Alexander, Professor at the University of Florida, “the history, of the school mascot, began in early intercollegiate sports. Schools needed a way to set apart their school, develop an air of uniqueness. The very first mascots appear at Ivy League schools, such as Yale, Harvard, and Brown. Cavemen used masks and costumes to gather strength for hunts and battles. The transition to the sports was only natural. The phenomenon grew and schools mascots quickly became household names and proud identifiers. The mascot signifies a proud heritage and continual identification by students well past graduation, embodying the spirit of the school.”
School mascots serve many purposes. They are the incentive for the student participation and enthusiasm. They provide a familiar rallying point, stand as a symbol, aid in giving a feeling of belonging, generate goodwill for the school, and remind students to never give up when behind. But what happens when the mascot one chooses is a caricature of another culture?
The Indian mascot would not be in existence without the centuries of stereotyping by Anglo-Americans. Indian stereotypes were only furthered by dime novels, blood and thunders, and early Hollywood westerns. These stereotypes made the American Indian larger than life and mythic, thereby allowing mascots to be created in this caricature of an image the Indian mascot was not based on reality, but instead based on imagination. In particular, the nineteenth century with its Wild West shows brought about a standard of representing Indians and the concept of “playing Indian.”
The American Indian stereotype was already in place and familiar to the American audiences by the World’s Fair in Chicago in 1893. Frederick Jackson Turner’s famed frontier thesis played into this romanticized view of the West, drawing on iconography of the frontier that his audience would already recognize. Buffalo Bill and his Wild West show played at the World’s Fair as well, telling the same story as Turner with different emphasis, especially towards the Native American. With little doubt, these two uses of frontier iconography, most notably the Indian, show that the stereotype of the Indian would not be easily removed from the American consciousness. After all, even those hoping to look at the West and Indians through an academic lens, such as Turner, were unable to avoid the stereotyped, romanticized view. As western historian Richard White says of Turner and Buffalo Bill: “Each erased part of the larger, and more confusing… cultural story in order to deliver up a clean, dramatic, and compelling narrative… precisely because they could mobilize familiar symbols, Buffalo Bill… and Frederick Jackson Turner... could persuade and convince their audiences” (White 49). Perhaps the most familiar symbol was the savage and the Indian warrior of the frontier. They were more than merely archetypes, they were nearly mascots of the frontier and of Buffalo Bill’s show.
Buffalo Bill and his show can be viewed as an early example of the American Indian sports mascot. Richard White concludes that, “Buffalo Bill created what now seems a postmodern West, in which performance and history were hopelessly intertwined” (White 53). A similar idea of performance and history is carried over in sports in the twentieth century. Green comments on mascots in the early twentieth century by stating they were “built around the passion for organized sport, and institutionalized through interscholastic competition, the twenties and thirties [brought]…the new Indian wars on the playing fields” (Green 42). A mascot is not far from playing Indian, which was on display in Buffalo Bill’s Wild West Show. How these mascots and logos were represented were no more evolved than the images Buffalo Bill used in promoting his show—Indians in full headdress as “savage assailants” (White 53). Green agrees that Indian mascots follow in this long tradition of “playing Indian”: “…the mascots, logos, paraphernalia, clothing, and names accompanying their redefined acts of war root their acts firmly in the mental and cultural construct of playing Indian” (Green 42).
The University of North Dakota’s mascot is currently the “Fighting Sioux,” but it hasn’t always been this way. In 1930, the university changed its mascot from “Flickertails” to “Fighting Sioux.” The name change was suggested by Professor Emeritus Alvin E. Austin, and according to student Holly Annis, this was because “Sioux are a good exterminating agent for the Bison; they are warlike, of fine physique and bearing, and the word Sioux is easily rhymed for yells and songs.” (Banks) It is interesting to note that it was nearly forty years later, in 1969, that a student group was finally formed that was related to Native American students. Before this time, there had been no Native American Student representation at the University of North Dakota, despite the fact that the school improperly co-opted the iconography of Native Americans. Regardless, within a year, UND’s Indian Association (UNDIA) began taking strong steps toward reinventing the image of Native Americans within the university (White 2001). Ever since, much debate and controversy have ensued regarding the schools use of The Fighting Sioux for their mascot.
The fundamental argument opposing the use of “Sioux” as a mascot name was brought to attention by UNDIA in 1970. At the time, UNDIA also protested the lack of adequate programs within the field of Indian Studies as well as the lack of adequate space and for the group to meet. Over the course of the following three years, the mascot name along with the student association fueled disharmony on campus. The university’s Greek life offended UNDIA members, protests were made, and surrounding businesses apparently practiced discrimination similar to occurrences of the civil rights movement of the south (White 2001).
In the early nineties, protests against the name were revitalized. In 1992 the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe called for an end to the use of their name, and a clear disconnect between within the public was made apparent when locals schools discontinued use of their Native American monikers and Native American children were harassed at the UND homecoming parade by the Greek community. Thus, SOAR (Students Organized Against Racism) was formed, which later evolved into Building Roads Into Diverse Groups Empowering Students (BRIDGES) (White 2001). This student group has effectively communicated “using any ethnic group as a moniker for a sports team is not respectful it is exploitive and leads to dangerous stereotypes and, subsequently, racism” (Banks). By the end of the decade, nine tribes had strongly disapproved of the “Fighting Sioux” mascot, along with many other committees, both within the university and across the nation. The President of the University of North Dakota, Charles Kupchella, suspended the use of the nickname and formed the Names Commission in 1999. It is interesting to note that this commission was created in order to study the moniker in a way, possibly to think up different ones, and not to decide whether the current Sioux mascot was appropriate.
Despite outward concern and intentions to “fix” the issue at hand, President Kupchella decided in late 1999 to keep the name. Afterward, in late 2000, a letter from Ralph Engelstad surfaced, which declared that a $1 million donation would be withheld from the university if the name should be changed. Of course, strong speculation saying that was the reason the North Dakota State Board of Higher Education pushed President Kupchella to maintain the “Fighting Sioux” moniker occurred. The construction of the new Engelstad Arena in 2001 probably did nothing to refute these speculations (White 2001).
The history of the mascot, and in particular the Native American as a mascot, is troublesome to contemporary thought. The history is steeped in racial prejudices and stereotypes. In Buffalo Bills Wild West Show, the Native American was portrayed as a caricature and as a villain. He fabricated an identity for an Indian based on small pieces of information that would be easily recognizable for his audiences. His Indian was not a representation of Native Cultures, but instead served as a new symbol meant to represent something for entertainment. He turned Native American culture into a spectacle which people had to pay to see.
As this caricaturial form of representation grew in popularity, sporting associations recognized the power of Native American iconography and began to use Buffalo Bills Indian caricatures to represent their teams. The Indian was reduced from the center of a spectacle, as it was in Buffalo Bills show, to cheerleader for a larger spectacle. Within sports, the Indian iconography used for a mascot becomes subordinate to the spectacle of the sport itself one cheers first for the team on the field, but rallies their cheer behind the image of the mascot. The mascot is not meant to be an accurate representation, but instead an appeal to a cloud of prejudices within a culture.
A name is just a word. It is a set of sounds which signify something other than the sound. We have access to meaning through language and therefore the meaning of a signifier is dependent upon its cultural connotations. In the same way that sounds produce meaning based upon culture, mascots also function. It is a symbol, an icon that gains relevance though cultural significance and there should be nothing intrinsically offensive about it. If its meaning is based on cultural markers, then the symbol itself is not the problem but instead it is how the symbol is understood within the culture. A mascot costume is just an outfit; thousands of yards of thread woven together with different colors to form a familiar body shape and face.
The problems that surround the use of Indian references in today’s sports mascots has origins that are evident through the history of Indian and non-Indian relations. A mascot is a person, animal, or object adopted by a group as a symbolic figure, especially to bring them luck. For any sports enthusiast, luck has long been something of an obsessive compulsive disorder to repeat actions taken previously to ensure success one must rely on superstition in hopes of a repeated outcome. If one wears their favorite basketball teams jersey on the day of the championship and that team wins, one repeats this ritual laboring under the impression that there is a correlation between them wearing the jersey and the victory of their favorite team. And with earlier, less-knowledgeable societies, the sports enthusiasts would have a very strong belief in this luck that it would bring a winning streak to the team. Betting on games with luck is a sure win, for many in the old days.
Mascots were mostly white males in gymnastics, able to do flips and stunts to pump up fans and rally them into a state of constant excitement for the sports game. If not for spectator satisfaction, the mascot would have no means of existing. The mascot is cheered for as much as the team, as the symbol of the mascot and the team itself are inseparable the mascot is not just a representation of the team, the mascot is the team.
Financing advertisements for professional athletics is a multi-million dollar expense. Contemporary advertising uses myriad formats to appeal to widest base of people, integrating print, broadcast, mailings, and billboards in a multifaceted attempt to sell a product. The firms that need that profit rely on the financial capacity of sports figures and their teams to bring in more market shares. As much as you’d wish to receive benefits, in the least, for the traumatic experiences some Indian individuals have faced, it is highly unlikely that all major sports teams, as well as, high school teams will lay down, bite the bullet and change their names (Burghart). The iconography of Indian mascots have been so well established that a professional sports team who has used Native American imagery for their mascots would commit financial suicide if they changed their mascot. A mascot is equivalent to a brand name a sports team who changes their mascot is akin to McDonalds abandoning their Golden Arches and changing their corporate logo.
The Florida State Seminoles have a very large fan base and with it comes high levels of loyalty to the sports’ mascots. Florida State is not the only team with this issue, yet it is figurehead for the issue of supporting tradition within the school. Children raised in contemporary culture don’t necessarily see the Indian as offensive or as an object of mockery, one sees it instead as a cultural “norm.” When thinking of a team or sports team it leads children to be proud of cheering on a team that is lead by a Native American mascot. Obviously, with populations such as this in America, there will always be support for preserving the iconography of their schools as tradition. When one cheers for the Florida State Seminoles, one does not cheer for the tribe, but instead they cheer for their team, school, and surrounding community.
Many people see using Indian mascots for sports’ teams as preserving a culture. Because sporting institutions are well established in American tradition, and with ninety-five percent of the population of natives being eradicated during white settlement, the preservation of an icon that is of Indian heritage would be the most ideal and logical alternative.
Along with the mascot name, the mascot clothing and looks, and mannerisms, comes the rooting language. They are entwined into the very fabric of the University’s cheers, and the impact on a whole student population would be substantial. The mascot is an integral part of the University, and to change the mascot results in changing the Universitys identity. Therefore with money, time, and energy sent in building up the integrity of sports mascots and their memorabilia, it is highly illogical to replace a mascot with a non-Indian appearance and the pros to preserving the Indian mascots are much greater.
There are many schools throughout the nation that have based themselves on Native American iconography. This has become a very pressing issue with tribal nations because many feel that it is offensive. However, there still exists a Native American population of the opinion the mascot name is honoring them. An example is how the North Dakota Fighting Sioux had Native American Veterans introduced with drums playing the traditional music of the Sioux Nation. This was a few hours before a hockey game and when one of the men was interviewed he said, “I'm honored that UND would use our name, our history shows we are a fighting people — and we're still fighting” (John Chaske). A whole university supports the Sioux Nation. They seek to champion the Sioux Nation as a strong and fighting people and instill that in their student body. The name Fighting Sioux is reminding us of the Sioux Nation and its culture. The way that schools depicts mascots actually honor Native Americans and help preserve Native American culture.
One must understand that institutions are not trying to hurt the Native American names and nations when they are used as mascots. Educational Institutions are trying to help the Native American communities by allowing their voices to be heard. The easiest way for that is if the institution’s mascot is based on Native American iconography. This way the Native American community is not forgotten and their voices can be heard through their use as a symbol which an entire institution can rally behind. Western History has glossed over Native Americans and their contributions they have been written as a people inhabiting land that European settlers wanted. Largely, their cultural contributions were not recorded into history, so for contemporary culture to recognize Native Nations, there must be something to get people’s attention that is not in a history book. This is where mascots can be used effectively. Because people feel intellectual and emotional proximity to their previous, present, or future educational institution, and the icon of the mascot is inseparable from the school, there is a reverence for the mascot that is inexorably linked to the institution. With this they can feel closer to Native Americans and will be more inclined to support the Native American communities. There is no disrespect or ill will intended towards the Native Americans and most Mascots are related to Native Americans in a positive way. Native Americans should vote for having schools adopt their names and honor their nations. This way they can honor themselves and preserve Native American culture, have the school support the Native Americans so they can be heard, and so that the US can focus on more pressing issues at the moment.
Still, the use of Native Americans as mascots is an issue surrounded with controversy. Although it is thought that the majority of Native Americans take offense when tribal names are used to represent team names that is not necessarily the case. Honoring bravery and courage, continuing traditions, and the acknowledgment of Native American tradition and impact in American are all very important factors to support that mascots should represent Native American culture.
In contemporary society, sports teams find it rewarding to use Native American cultures as a mascot they adopt the imagery and names in attempt to gesture towards Native Nations and their cultural values and impact. Sports Illustrated conducted a survey among Native Americans, both living on and off the reservation and also fans of the sports teams. Within the 1,000 people that were surveyed, the Peter Harris Research group, working closely with Sports Illustrated discovered surprising results. “With a margin of error of ±4%, 83% of the Indians said that professional teams should not stop using Indian nicknames, mascots or symbols, and 79% of the fans agreed with them (Woo 69). Ironically, there is a greater difference of opinion between the Indians living on and off the reservation than there is between the Native Americans and the sports fans who are not part of Native American culture. These statistics, with results indicating that a majority of the population of both Native Americans and non-Native Americans support Native American mascots, give mascots and their fans reassurance in the importance of Native American representation as mascots by teams throughout the country.
The continuous representation of the Native American culture is practiced through mascots to honor and acknowledge their traditions. Songs and dances are two ways Native Americans exhibit traditional values and mascots are able to incorporate these into their spectacles on the sports field. The use of mascots is not meant to be offensive or degrading, but rather they are meant to exonerate Native American culture and support the team they are associated with. Superintendent Mary Alice Fletcher defends their new Indian mascot, “It was done strictly to create school spirit because theyre proud of their Indian heritage (Good Voice 4). The Stilwell High School, located in Stillwell, Oklahoma, has a large population of Cherokee students, who were very accepting of their new mascot. Other members of the Cherokee Nation began to criticize this new mascot. The students were very familiar with the traditions of this tribe and were able to promote the Tomahawk identity for their school. The staff writer of the Cherokee Phoenix, Christina Good Voice writes, “CN citizen and Stilwell alumna Melanie Knight said she was disappointed the school would create a mascot that is a caricature and warped image of American Indians (10). The Native people who take offense to the mascots believe they are making fun of the physical features and active traditions the Tomahawk nation practices, but that was definitely not their intention. As these disagreements between supporters and non-supporters of Tomahawk iconography continue, it show that there are differing opinions both positive and negative that remain about mascots.
Many locations throughout our nation have Native American presence, which have given identity to multiple sports teams. “Over the years, this pattern has given us the Kansas City Chiefs, Chicago Blackhawks, Cleveland Indians, Florida State Seminoles, Atlanta Braves and Washington Redskins (to name a few)” (Dewitt 4). This writer for CBS sports continues to express the controversies that have rose from the mascot debate. Sports Illustrated conducted a survey to gather opinions on the representation of these native tribes and again found the majority of the Native cultures to be accepting of these mascots. They do not take offense to their native identity given to the sports teams, but rather they feel honored. They like to see their land and traditions they practice extended into events outside of the native culture.
Many tribes take pride and honor in the names that have been given to the multiple sports teams. It is not intended to be offensive, but rather a continuing of their culture and increased opportunity for their traditions to be celebrated in different environments and to survive into contemporary society. Mascots are able to practice similar rituals and tradition as the native tribes, which display their way of life and incorporate their culture into the sporting event.
However, when considering the contingency supporting mascots in America, one must observe that it not solely for exemplification of Native American cultures. There is an economic factor that motivates the use of Native American iconography for mascots and spectacles. Buffalo Bill and his Wild West Show concocted an Indian identity to sell to the general American public, while athletic institutions face economic losses if they attempt to create a new mascot with an established team. It stands to reason that one may perpetuate or create racial stereotypes as a means of increasing profits. This economic force has the power to reduce any Native Nation to a caricature and a commodity if mascots are symbols meant to represent something from the world, and athletic institutions are profiting from these symbols, then one must question if mascots pay proper respect to the tribe the iconography is taken from, or if the athletic institutions are profiting from stereotypes and caricatures.
The biggest and most notable representation and disputed Native American mascot is that of the University of North Dakota’s Fighting Sioux. The name is both derogatory and misrepresentative of the community and does nothing to benefit the Dakota of the surrounding areas.
David Gipp, a Lakota and president of the United Tribes Technical College also in North Dakota says that the Fighting Sioux, “is a pejorative name given to the Lakota by Europeans and does not accurately describe who we are.” By having a group of people represent your school does not automatically put you on their good side. In fact, in this case, it does quite the opposite (Help 1-2). There is a reason for such a strong level of aversion to these mascots. They are icons used to represent an institution imbued with the responsibility to properly educate students who seek college degrees. Gipp makes a point to say that as a place of learning the college has a “fundamental responsibility to create an environment where every racial group is respected. There is no such thing as an 'honorable' denigration of a race or group of people (Help 1-2).”
After Clarence W. Skye of the United Sioux Tribes Development Corp wrote to then
UND President Dr. Kendell Baker that various Sioux tribes did not object to the team name,
Letters from other tribes wrote the UMD in protest of Skyes statement. In a strongly worded letter to the University, the Former Chairman Andrew Grey Sr. of the Sisseton-Wahpeton Sioux Tribe wrote,
"Use of a race of people as a nickname or mascot is totally unacceptable and only leads to the dehumanization of their being, culture, history, and children. Only when one is in this situation can you truly understand the full impact of such demeaning and dehumanizing behavior. What do we tell our beautiful children when they are subjected to such acts either personally or when they have to read or hear about their ancestors as nicknames or mascots and not humans?" (Banks).

Former President Norman G. Wilson of the Rosebud Sioux Tribe wrote, "I am saddened and deeply concerned about the continued use of the 'Fighting Sioux' as it mimics and shows complete disrespect for the Sioux Tribe. The reason is obvious and clear. This practice of using the 'Fighting Sioux' shows the complete lack of acknowledgement of this indigenous race of people. Our people have a beautiful history, culture, and legacy that should not be subject to such demeaning acts for any reason, at any time. I might add that one act is too many and warrants the immediate elimination of the 'Fighting Sioux' nickname at the University of North Dakota.” (Banks).
Harold D. Salway, former president of the Oglala Sioux Tribe wrote, "As we enter a new century there isn't any justifiable reason to continue to dehumanize a race of people." (Banks)
Gregg J. Bourland, former chairman of the Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe wrote, "Humanity has come a long way in the last one hundred years. Institutes of higher learning have helped to make that happen. The use of Native Americans (putting us in the same class as animals) is one of the last barriers facing colleges and universities to a real fulfillment of higher learning." (Banks)



Lenzy Krehbiel compares the use of derogatory and colonial terminology in the names of mascots to racial epithets (Krehbiel). No race, nation or culture must be represented by terms meant to disenfranchise and disparage the very ones they represent. The times have changed and just as we no longer treat women as property, neither should we misrepresent Native Americans and use their “image” as a source of entertainment. A statement from The Spirit Lake Sioux, "(The Spirit Lake Sioux) finds that the use of the Fighting Sioux and Sioux names by the University of North Dakota is both dishonorable and an affront to the dignity and well being of the members of Spirit Lake"
A former tribal chairman of the Spirit Lake tribe, Skip Longie, contrary to what North Dakota officials have said, says that Spitit Lake does not support the use of the name. According to him the authorization of the use of the name came in 2000 under conditions that required the college to give a mandatory sensitivity course to all incoming freshman. Visits to the reservatiosn would also be available to the students. "To my understanding, I don't think the university has done any of those things," Longie said (Sioux).
By using the images of the Indian as logos it is further oppressing the people it is supposed to represent. According to Michael Eshkibok, “American Indian students endure the psychological damage and dehumanizing effects of seeing these cartoons of themselves” (Eshkibok).
On the Nanticoke Lenni-Lenape webpage they have a statement about Native American mascots in which they say that most further instill insensitivity where their children often go to school and see “their race is being caricatured on walls, shirts, jackets and flags (Frequently).”
They say their ceremonies and heroes are turned into marketing tools and that the perpetrators are unwilling and fight back when attempts to educate them are made.
Angelique EagleWoman feels the representation of her male ancestors are being placed on the same level as animals. This dehumanization continues the damage done by Hollywood westerns by portraying them as two dimensional people whose only care in life is to fight (EagleWoman).
Chase Iron Eyes, a Standing Rock Sioux, says the problem he has with mascots is not the names but the objectification of his race. He believes the objectification is damaging the way Native Americans view themselves (Iron Eyes).
Indigenous affairs within Western culture have always been approached with a different standard. The perspectives on Indigenous life vary, yet stereotype is the common existence for Indigenous peoples. The stereotypes may never be eradicated but there are accessible and direct outlets for change. A primary resource is a better understanding by academia. Colleges and universities are now teaching proper materials regarding Indigenous life and their overall participation in America as we know it today. However, as they laud their American Indian departments, not much has changed in their overall representation, namely their emblems and mascots. The University of North Dakota is at the forefront of this issue in both regards. The university is among the nation’s leaders in graduating Native students, and has produced over twenty-percent of the nations Native doctors. (Tovares 88). However, Indigenous people comprise 5.5% of the state’s population, while the “Fighting Sioux” is representative of the state as a whole (2000 Census). The university prides itself in its athletics as there are no major professional sports teams in the state. Although they are one among roughly 80 colleges and universities to use Indigenous names, images, or references, they have become a primary target of Indigenous groups (King 316). The university has created this dichotomy for seemingly all of the right and wrong reasons.
The “Fighting Sioux” emblem and nickname has become more than an improper pursuit of “honor, pride, tradition, and respect” to the university (Tovares 92). It is rooted in imperialism, through the control of Native Americans and the reworking of what it is to be Indian both past and present (King 317). The nostalgia of the past has not seemed to wane in present times. Outside of the motives of Ralph Engelstad, the argument for keeping the “Fighting Sioux” mascot has come full circle in order to again “triumph” over Indigenous cultures. The inception of the mascot was meant to continue the power felt after the closing of the frontier, and to further stamp the ideals of what it is to be “American” (King 316). It has continued this pursuit by masking Indigenous identity with the continued use of Native mascots in white constructions to further demean and assimilate Indigenous culture (Black 616). The use of Native mascots is therefore a direct attack on the identity of past and present Indigenous peoples. In the guise of a mascot, Western society continues to express the “superiority” of mainstream America. Indigenous peoples are then “trapped” by their heritage through Western and often their own eyes (Black 616). In the case of UND perhaps the most troubling aspect is that the fight has become more about the fight than the mascot itself.
Considering the mismanagement of Native peoples post takeover, it would appear the higher educational systems could remedy the situation. The NCAA has done a small part in changing the landscape of racist mascots yet, continues to leave room for “exemptions” (Staurowsky 73). UND has migrated through the Western structures to remain the “Fighting Sioux” however have made no strides from a moral standpoint. The university had released a statement roughly ten years ago stating, “The University of North Dakota is firmly committed to promoting an environment that emphasizes respect for diversity. In accordance with this commitment, the UND community is dedicated to respecting the past and present of the American Indians” (Staurowsky 89). It is the reader’s responsibility to decide the truths of this statement. Unfortunately it appears not much has changed in present times. The only true way to honor a tribe would be to retire the Indian mascot (Black 617). For now the fight continues and any attempt to reclaim Indianness is positive.
One can see that the factions supporting and non supporting the use of Native American iconography are intellectually at odds. Neither side of the issue is intrinsically on the right side, so to speak, yet there are passionate supporters on both sides. With such separation in opinion on a national scale, it became necessary to gather local opinions though interview there was not an objectively correct side of the issue, therefore we sought opinions from our community regarding the issue of Native Americans being used as mascots.
First, we conducted some interviews with Native American adolescents. With the passing of generations, Native culture has been lost or has faded away through time several Native languages have become extinct with the bereavement of the last living elders of many tribes, and although Native pride is still very alive in these tribes, culture and tradition has become more modernized, and many customs have been willingly eradicated. To relate this to the controversy of mascots in the large-scale media, it becomes a matter of changing from strict and conservative culture to a more contemporary one that is better suited to function well in contemporary America.
With the new Native generations comes a waning away from such traditional values and an acclimation towards those of Caucasian and Americanized society. This is why, we believe, that the responses to the interviews regarding adolescent’s opinions of mascots were fairly neutral. One could conclude that values have changed over generations or perhaps there has been a decrease in Native pride, resulting in the nonchalance of young people faced with their culture being misused as a symbol to accrue profit. Or are there simply more important issues presently for the Native culture to deal with? According to Lindsey Fenner of the Golden Eagles/ Ginew program at the Minnesota American Indian Center, who has discussed this issue at various times with the children that participate, the latter is undeniably true. These children, of approximately ten to thirteen years of age, were fairly flabbergasted when approached about their views of the use of stereotypical, violent Native mascots in the sports media. Most did not have any strong opinions on the topic, claiming that they did not think the mascots were doing any harm to the their culture.
Others donned a quizzical expression, explaining that they had never thought about the matter, let alone even knew such a controversy existed. “I think that, presently, the Native community has much more important things to be thinking about and that for children to dirty their minds with these matters is useless. Children do not think in this way, they are not programmed to be expecting hateful behavior at every turn,” describes Ms. Fenner. Yet, children are subjected to the biased opinions of their parents, grandparents, and other family members, and these influences greatly mold the lives of young people. Perhaps Native American tradition and way of life is fading quickly. I believe it to be true that the disparity between groups of Native Americans adds to the differing opinions on this subject. The sense of preservation among tribes varies greatly, and many elders feel that such representation is exploitation when used to entertain the white man. One must consider if these values are being passed on to generations, or if these strong feeling of degradation will be outdated. It is undeniable that mascots no not accurately represent Native American Nations and that they project negative sterotypes onto Native Americans. It may be the case that Native Youth see other issues of the world as more important than their culture co-opted for a mascot, yet one must question how the youth in contemporary American society will respond to issues regarding their culture, such as the use of mascots.
One must question if the beliefs and values of Native Americans are being considered when they are selected as a mascot. It has been indicated that Americans of non-Native decent believe that it is a way of honoring the Native Americans by naming national or high school mascots after them, that it is in some way giving them something that they deserve. The question is whether Native Americans feel that naming mascots after them is in an honor. Do mascot names such as warriors or redskins honor Native Americans? According to some it is not an honor but an insult.
Walter Riplinger, a member of the Lakota and active within local tribes of Central Minnesota, said that naming of mascots after them is a way for the dominant whites to make themselves feel better about the treaties that they did not honor. Walter also said that they believe that is a way for them to make their conscious mind feel better as well.
Walter Riplinger grew up in central Minnesota and graduated from Hopkins High School. During the time that he went to Hopkins High School they were known as the Warriors. The homecoming king and queen at Hopkins High School would wear war bonnets and eagle feathers during the homecoming celebrations. Walter greatly disagreed with using the name warrior to represent the school and the use of war bonnets and eagle feathers.
Often when Native American names, believes, and traditions are used it is an insult because of the meaning behind the names and traditions. For example Native Americans like to be considered a peaceful group and the name warrior is a way of remembering them with violence. Another example is the use of war bonnets and eagle feathers that members of Hopkins High School and other schools have used. According to Native American beliefs war bonnets and eagle feathers are something that one must earn, and the iconography used by whites dishonors Native Americans and their beliefs. The names used for mascots also tend to be a dishonor.
Often the names used for mascots are actually a great dishonor because of the story behind the name and what it means to Native Americans. A great example is the name Redskins often used for mascots. The name redskin is a racial epithet redskin is a name that metonymically represents an entire nation using only the color of their skin (a color which is not a skin tone, akin to other racial misnomers of black, white, yellow, etc.). According to Walter Riplinger the name redskin comes from a hateful background given by white Americans and fur traders.
The name redskin comes from a background very different from the one that non- Native Americans know. Walter Riplinger said according to Native American stories scalping actually came to the Native Americans and the United States from Europe. It was the Europeans who taught the Native Americans the art of scalping. It was this scalping that brought the hateful term redskins to the American Indians. The government once offered a bounty for all Native American scalps. The bounty hunters got overly greedy and started to scalp dark haired ‘Americans’. The government got frustrated and required that the whole skin of the Native American be brought in. When a skin was brought in to receive the bounty it was generally bloody and therefore red. It was from these bloody skins that the term Redskin originated and was applied to Native Americans.
It is not only the term Redskins that Americans do not know the Native meaning to it. There are many other terms that have a meaning that may not be honoring to Native Americans but White Americans do not know the story behind them or the true meaning and believe that they are actually honoring the Native Americans. Some other terms that are actually insulting to Native Americans are squaw, which literally translates to vagina. Also according to Walter Riplinger the word Sioux is a derivative of an Anishinabae word that translates to enemy or literally to ‘little snake’.
When asked whether what they would like done about mascots that are named after their beliefs and such most Native Americans replied that they would like them all to be changed to something that is not based on Native Americans. Hopkins High School was once referred to as the Warriors but changed their mascot to the Hawkeyes this change was looked upon by as a good change. It is not thought of to be referring to Native Americans in any way and that is what most would prefer be done.
Although they would want this change to be done they realize that is can be a very long difficult process. One person even stated that they know that it is something that is very involved with money and politics. They mentioned North Dakota State University and that it is a place where politics and money have more influence over the mascot then their wishes to have the mascot changed from the Fighting Sioux.
We sought to interview as diverse a sample as possible, thus it was necessary to speak with people who supported Native American iconography being used for mascots. We spoke with Steve Hart, who is a fan of the Chicago Blackhawks hockey team. This team was founded in 1926 when Frederic McLaughlin acquired the Portland Rosebuds and moved them to the Chicago area. There, the new hockey team was positioned to play in National Hokey League. McLaughlin named the team after a Native American from the1800s with the name Black Hawk. McLaughlin also served in the US Army as the commander of the 333rd Machine-Gun Battalion of the 85th (Blackhawk) division. He chose the Native American name to commemorate the military unit in which he served. Irene Castle, his wife and famous dancer from the 1920s, designed the logo with a Native American looking to the left in profile (Sports Encyclopedia).
Today, Illinois has no federally recognized tribes within its borders. The native tribes were forced by the US government to move into Indian reservations in Oklahoma. The original tribes in the area were: The Chickasaw tribe, The Dakota Sioux tribe, The Ho-Chunk tribe (Winnebago), The Illinois tribe (Illini), The Miami tribe and The Shawnee tribe. The roots of the actual name of the state come from the Miami-Illinois tribal name Illiniwek that is “the people” (Illinios).
Steve proudly wears a jacket with the logo of the Chicago Blackhawks emblazoned upon it. I asked him if he would like to answer a few questions regarding his team and about the mascot. He agreed and we walked through the campus of the University of Minnesota while conducting our interview. I asked him for how long he had been a fan of the Blackhawks. He grew up in Chicago and has supported the Blackhawks since he was a child, more than thirty-five years ago. Even after moving to Minnesota he still has remained a fan of the Blackhawks and follows their games.
Our conversation continued with questions about the mascot he was wearing on his jacket. I was curious about the face depicted on the back. Steve said that it is the face of a Native American and it is supposed to embody the strength, courage and the fighting spirit of the hockey team. He also told me how the use of Native American symbolism has been at the heart of great controversy for many teams in US. I asked him what he thought of the use of the mascot by teams not associated in any way to the Native’s culture. He did not see that as a problem and claimed that it is respectful to the Natives in that it positively promotes their culture.
My next interviewer arrived from a trip to Romania. During the trip I made a parallel to the discrimination the Rroma nomads encounter because of their lifestyle and the Natives in United States.
Some of my friends agreed to answer some of my questions about Native Americans and the use of mascots for sports teams in US. Darius Scheible and his friend Alice participated in the short-lived discussion. Did they know anything about the Native Americans from US? Darius recollected that as a kid, around 1982 he used to play with cowboys and Indians, plastic toys. More often the Indians were bad and the cowboys were the good guys. That is how the western movies portrayed them. I asked him if “Indians “exists anymore or have been assimilated in current US culture. He did not know. Did he think that the use of Native symbolism is benefic for the culture of the tribes? He did not see a problem with it. I was interested in his opinion in that should the Natives be assimilated in mainstream US culture or not? His said that the tribes have a unique individuality that it is expressed in the language, traditions, and cultural values. If Natives exists anymore they should be allowed to maintain their uniqueness. What we have drawn from that conversation is that the majority of Romanians should think the same about their own Rroma minority.
Our next interview was with a peer who traces his roots back to the Cherokee nation, Lynn Bush. Our interviewer knows him through a spring tradition of mushroom hunting. Mr. Bush and he mushroom hunt together when the lilacs bloom in the spring he has learned not to use the calendar for the hunt as it begins on the day that the lilac blooms and the season ends two weeks after. He was not bothered by mascots and was not against using mascots by sports teams. He said d it was fine with it but he knew of other Native Americans who did not agree with using mascots.
Our last interview was with Tozzie Titus, a nurse working at the Fairview Hospital. She was a supporter of the California Indians, a university of California mascot from the mid 20th century. The team city used a Native American individual who paraded around as an Indian mascot. She said it was promoting a positive image to the Natives. If anything, Native Americans would only benefit from the use of their cultural symbols and would be made known to the rest of the people.
The use of Native Americans and their cultural iconography as mascots in professional, collegiate and other athletic organizations is not something which can be easily resolved. The issue is dichotomously split there is small middle ground between supporters and non-supporters and both poles of the issue feel strongly. We could not see an objective resolution between the two sides, thus the issue remains complicated and subjective. What we did conclude was that the population who supports Native American iconographical representation as mascots did so because they felt it honored Native American cultural values, because to change the mascot from Native American iconography would mean financial repercussions, or because they saw Native American mascots as keeping Native culture alive. Those who did not support Native American mascots did so because they felt the mascots grossly misrepresented them and their culture, were an offensive co-option of culture and values, and perpetuated stereotypes.
A mascot is a caricature it is a symbol with easily identifiable connotations which sports fans can rally behind. While a mascot, such as Chicagos hockey team The Blackhawks, can be used to represent bravery and courage, the same symbol also has the power to disenfranchise and degrade the very culture it represents. One must question whether they can support iconography that has this amount of power on one hand the image of The Blackhawks is a rallying point for hockey fans and they have a positive opinion of the symbol, almost reverent, while simultaneously it degrades Native Nations because it is a caricature of a culture and does not accurately represent Native values.

Thursday, February 25, 2010

For sending your parts of the paper,

email them to me at smudgesellswater@gmail.com

- mark

Saturday, February 20, 2010

Postin our parts of the paper...

How would you like us to post our parts of the paper?
Tiffany

Monday, February 8, 2010

Some Interview Questions

Feel free (anyone) to give feedback to these questions. I am planning to address youth, so I sort of tailor made the questions to do that. Thanks!

1) What is your opinion on the use of Native American mascots in American sports today?  2) Do you feel that your opinion differs from the opinions of adults, such as your parents or grandparents?  3) Do you feel that the use of mascots gives Native Americans a negative connotation, or a violent image?  4) On a scale of 1-10, how strongly do you feel about this issue? (One being neutral, and ten being very against the use of mascots or very in favor of them.. just in case)  Let me know if you have any more ideas for me. I feel like however someone will answer these questions could lead me to ask other questions based on the answers, so this is just a rough outline.

Saturday, February 6, 2010

Great Places to Start Looking

Don't forget about our lovely library system. The indexes alone have many, many sources for our topic!
Academic Search Premier (http://www.lib.umn.edu/indexes/a)
Project Muse
ProQuest Databases (http://www.lib.umn.edu/indexes/p)
Ethnic Newswatch
Alternative Press Index

e-journal (type name into search bar)
American Indian Quarterly
American Indian Law Review
Native American Connections

websites:
http://thecirclenews.org/
http://www.indiancountrytoday.com/
http://www.nativeculturelinks.com/media.html
http://www.press-on.net/
http://www.reznetnews.org/
http://www.hanksville.org/NAresources/indices/NAmedia.html


Tuesday, February 2, 2010

teams

Teams
For- Javier/Gabe/Brandi
Against- Nora/Brian/Alden
Interviews-Jaimie/Emma/Dragos
History-Tiffany/Patton/Erin
Intro/Finalization- Mark
Timekeeper/Researcher-Matt

Saturday, January 30, 2010

Ginew/ Golden Eagle

Hi everyone-

For a Public Life Literature class I am currently taking, I am doing a sort of service-learning track where I will be starting a volunteer job at the Ginew/Golden Eagle organization on Cedar in Minneapolis (I think in close proximity to the Little Earth American Indian community). I'm really excited because I will be working with Native American youth and can possibly ask them about their position on the topic of mascots? Does anyone else think that is a good idea to include in our research?

Thursday, January 28, 2010

Scandinavians' feelings towards Vikings...

Something to think about- What is the difference between mascots like the Vikings and mascots of Native Americans? People of Scandinavian descent don't show nearly as much adversion to the portrayal of the Vikings as Native Americans do about teams like the Fighting Sioux or Chicago Blackhawks.

Some ideas:
-The Vikings are extinct. Natives Americans are obviously still alive.
-The integrity of the mascot and the way it's portrayed.

Wednesday, January 27, 2010

Mascot Jumping Off Points

I think Alex wanted us to do a case study or two regarding mascots in the five state area, this way we will find the most people in the easiest way with opinions regarding semi-local mascots. I feel that when looking at the etymology of the word mascot, one should also consider what the symbol of the mascot means to a fan (this will most likely come up in research). There is something strange about how one can cheer for the Vikings as a whole team, but on average not be able to name more than a handful of players. Thus the fans dont identify the team as individuals but instead as collective abstractly shaped by the symbol with which they are recognized. I thought it would be interesting to ask U of M students how they feel being a Gopher. Gophers are nuisances to most humans, and I dont feel too wonderful about the icon of my school being more or less vermin.

I spoke with Alex after class, and I am sure you read it in the syllabus also, but the page requirement for this project sits at 25. This breaks down into a couple of pages of writing for each of us. Luckily, this is not going to be as stressful as we all think it is. I think it would be an effective and pertinent strategy to split into 4-5 smaller subtopics, as have been mentioned in the earlier posts, and in smaller groups work on a 5-6 page essay regarding a single topic. As I said during class, I will do the editing for this project as a whole. This is my proposal for everyone,

By March 26th, this is the last Friday in March, I would like 5-6 page essays on each of the topics we decide to research. This will give me enough time over the weekend to read, edit, and write the larger paper connecting the dots between the subtopics and addressing a main thesis. That following Monday I will have been able to email you the draft I have completed and we can talk about it in class, this will then give me one more week to do finishing touches and re-writes. I will make a note about this now, that is proofread your papers. I dont want to be handed something wrought with punctuation, spelling, and grammar errors that could have been easily rectified with proofreading and quick edits.

How does this sound?

Tuesday, January 26, 2010

My 2 cents

I was thinking that for the paper we could cover all sides:
Pro
Con
Interviews (the Peoples thoughts)
History of Teams with Native mascots and the controversies surrounding them
(a basic overview)

I say this because I doubt that we would be able to make this paper into a one sided issue and it would be nice to have it be journalistic in the sense that it represents ALL sides because everyone's voice should be heard. It would also be nice to have an overview of this issue to ground it in something that is unbiased (or as unbiased as "facts" can be).

Also for a time line in weeks:
1 (now) initial individual research
2 (Feb 1-7) Assign teams and meet IRL or Virtually
3 (Feb 8-14) research
4 (Feb 15-21) write
5 (Feb 22-28) rough drafts posted to blog and read by others with feedback e-mailed to authors
6 (Mar 1-7) revision
7 (Mar 8-14) finalization

E-mail all final products to Mark on Monday March 15th

If I got that right the weeks should come out to be in to the editors during spring break.

You don't need to post what you think of the time line (as agreed we will go over this at the beginning of class next Monday). But if you could "comment" (see button below) about the outline for the paper (see above) that would be great.

The fighting Sioux

Washington Post has an article from 2005 in which the use of "the fighting Sioux" mascot is a big controversy at North Dakota university. NCAA has banned the use of Native American logos by teams and the school is divided in pro/con groups. Some say the use of such logos is discriminatory while others say the use of these logos helps the image of the tribes. Anyway, if we can come up with a short introduction about mascots linked to the tribes and a thesis in which we support or not the use of mascots then we can start mapping researchable topics in support of our thesis. My idea is that if all in the group brainstorm of a couple of issues then we can go on our ways to research them and write 2-3 pages about it for a total of 25. Some can interview people on reservations or at the casinos. Others can research the use of mascots in US history or cases in courts regarding legal issues from mascots depicting tribal images, et cetera.

Monday, January 25, 2010

Notes from class

Alex said we should stick within the 5 state area. I am pretty sure he means North/South Dakota, Minnesota and Wisconsin....but which is the 5th? Iowa? Illinois? He suggested we look up the etymology of the word "mascot". He also brought up checking into how native youth feel about cheering for a team that has an Indian/Native mascot.